mdthr

syllogisms on gender copula

Jan 3rd, 2023
66
0
Never
Not a member of Pastebin yet? Sign Up, it unlocks many cool features!
text 1.73 KB | None | 0 0
  1. 1) If the objective quality of gender were to exist, it would be an inherent characteristic of an individual that either can or cannot be changed.
  2. 2) If everyone could use a copula for any gender, it would be possible for an individual to change their objective quality of gender.
  3. c) Therefore, if everyone can use a copula for any gender, the objective quality for any gender does not exist independently or as an inherent characteristic of any individual, but rather it is a construct that is not tied to the objective reality of an individual.
  4.  
  5. 1) If the primary quality of gender can be changed, then it is dependent on something external to the individual.
  6. 2) If a quality is dependent on something external to the individual, then it does not exist in the individual in the same way that an inherent characteristic would.
  7. c) Therefore, if the objective quality of gender can be changed, then "gender" would exist as an objective quality that is dependent on something external to the individual, and at some point does not exist in the individual in the same way that an inherent characteristic would.
  8.  
  9. 1) If the objective quality of gender were to exist, it would be an inherent characteristic of an individual that either can or cannot be changed.
  10. 2) If the objective quality of gender can be changed, then it is dependent on something external to the individual.
  11. c) Therefore, if the objective quality of gender can be changed, then any particular specification of gender does not exist independently.
  12.  
  13. this basically means the idea of male and female doesn't exist except as something dependent on factors external to what human beings inherently are. which is ridiculous, since male and female does exist as inherent qualities to human beings.
  14.  
Advertisement
Add Comment
Please, Sign In to add comment